The 4 jhānas have 7☀️ factors. Not 5.

seven golden dragon eggs hatching around a monk on a mountain top: the 4 jhanas have 7 awakening factors, not 5

A teaser for a revised page on lucid24.org: 7 not 5 — jhāna factors.
The full page has the sutta citations,
the Visuddhimagga passage,
and the collapsible outline.
This is the short version and the conclusion.

The claim

The four jhānas have seven jhāna factors, not five.

The seven are the 7sb☀️: satta bojjh-aṅgā,
the seven awakening factors.

1🐘 sati — remembering [the ☸Dharma one needs]
2💭🕵️ dhamma-vicaya — ☸Dharma investigation
3🏹 vīriya — vigor
4😁 pīti — rapture
5🌊 passaddhi — pacification
6🌄 samādhi — undistractible-lucidity
7🛆👁 upekkhā — equanimous-observation

Three of them — upekkhā, sati and dhamma-vicaya — are capable of vipassanā.

That is precisely why the LBT 5-jhāna-factor scheme omits them.

Why it matters

The LBT 5 jhāna factors are vitakka, vicāra,
pīti, sukha and citt’ekaggatā.
Set them beside the seven and what is missing is not random.
sati is not on the list at all.
Neither is dhamma-vicaya.
Those are the two faculties that remember a ☸Dharma and investigate it.

That leaves vitakka and vicāra as the only candidates — and the LBT redefines those two as “initial and sustained attention” rather than thinking and evaluating,
so they cannot investigate anything either.
By second jhāna they are gone anyway.
From there the scheme leaves pīti, sukha and ekaggatā; then sukha and ekaggatā; then upekkhā and ekaggatā.
Not one of those can remember a ☸Dharma,
investigate one, or discern what is happening.

Conclusion

The four jhānas have seven factors.
Not five.

🐘 sati   💭🕵️ dhamma-vicaya   🏹 vīriya   😁 pīti   🌊 passaddhi   🌄 samādhi   👁 upekkhā

The LBT 5-jhāna-factor scheme appears twice in the whole EBT,
both times from Sāriputta and never from the Buddha.
The seven appear throughout SN 46 as independent factors,
and again as a causal sequence.
The three that the LBT 5-jhāna-factor scheme drops — upekkhā,
sati and dhamma-vicaya — are precisely the three that do vipassanā.

That is why the redefinition matters.
With the LBT 5 jhāna factors the jhānas become a frozen samatha exercise.

two conspirators push two of the seven golden eggs off the cliff, leaving five petrified monks: the 5-jhāna-factor conspiracy

With seven, they are where insight happens.

Each of the 4 jhānas has 7 awakening jhāna factors.
The 7sb sequence is both causal and independent,
and both samatha and vipassanā happen in each jhāna.

Read the full argument

The complete page — MN 78 on vīriya as an independent factor the five leave out,
SN 46.2 and SN 46.4, the twenty meditation subjects of SN 46,
MN 43 where Sāriputta makes the claim,
the Visuddhimagga’s “five magical soul mates” passage on the five hindrances,
and MN 53 on the jhāna formula as meditation instructions — is at:

🔗 lucid24.org/sted/8aam/8samadhi/jhana-factors

Liked this? Get new posts by email.

Better yet, discuss this post on the forum — comments to the blog here often get spammed and ignored.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe

New writing on early Buddhism, sent as it's published. One email address, no account.